Los equipos All-American del baloncesto de la NCAA 1951, que destacan a los mejores jugadores universitarios de cada curso, fueron elegidos por Associated Press, United Press International, Look Magazine, International News Service y Collier's.
| Jugador | Posición | Curso[1] | Equipo |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clyde Lovellette | C | Junior | Kansas |
| Gene Melchiorre | G | Senior | Bradley |
| Bill Mlkvy | F | Junior | Temple |
| Sam Ranzino | G | Senior | North Carolina State |
| Bill Spivey | C | Junior | Kentucky |
| Jugador | Posición | Curso | Equipo |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ernie Barrett | G/F | Senior | Kansas State |
| Bill Garrett | F | Senior | Indiana |
| Dick Groat | G | Junior | Duke |
| Mel Hutchins | F/C | Senior | Brigham Young |
| Gale McArthur | G | Senior | Oklahoma A&M |
| Equipo All-America | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Primer equipo | Segundo equipo | Tercer equipo | ||||||
| Jugador | Universidad | Jugador | Universidad | Jugador | Universidad | |||
| Associated Press[2] | Clyde Lovellette | Kansas | Ernie Barrett | Kansas State | John Azary | Columbia | ||
| Gene Melchiorre | Bradley | Bill Garrett | Indiana | Mel Hutchins | Brigham Young | |||
| Bill Mlkvy | Temple | Dick Groat | Duke | Frank Ramsey | Kentucky | |||
| Sam Ranzino | North Carolina State | Gale McArthur | Oklahoma A&M | Whitey Skoog | Minnesota | |||
| Bill Spivey | Kentucky | Bob Zawoluk | St. John's | Mark Workman | West Virginia | |||
| UPI | Clyde Lovellette | Kansas | John Azary | Columbia | Ernie Barrett | Kansas State | ||
| Gene Melchiorre | Bradley | Bill Garrett | Indiana | Mel Hutchins | Brigham Young | |||
| Bill Mlkvy | Temple | Dick Groat | Duke | Frank Ramsey | Kentucky | |||
| Sam Ranzino | North Carolina State | Gale McArthur | Oklahoma A&M | Whitey Skoog | Minnesota | |||
| Bill Spivey | Kentucky | Bob Zawoluk | St. John's | Don Sunderlage | Illinois | |||
| Look Magazine[3] | Mel Hutchins | Brigham Young | John Azary | Columbia | Dick Groat | Duke | ||
| Gale McArthur | Oklahoma A&M | Ernie Barrett | Kansas State | Gene Melchiorre | Bradley | |||
| Bill Mlkvy | Temple | Bill Garrett | Indiana | Ray Ragelis | Northwestern | |||
| Sam Ranzino | North Carolina State | Clyde Lovellette | Kansas | Mark Workman | West Virginia | |||
| Bill Spivey | Kentucky | Whitey Skoog | Minnesota | Bob Zawoluk | St. John's | |||
| International News Service | Ernie Barrett | Kansas State | Sin segundo ni tercer equipo | |||||
| Mel Hutchins | Brigham Young | |||||||
| Gene Melchiorre | Bradley | |||||||
| Bill Mlkvy | Temple | |||||||
| Bill Spivey | Kentucky | |||||||
| Collier's | Clyde Lovellette | Kansas | John Azary | Columbia | Sin tercer equipo | |||
| Gene Melchiorre | Bradley | Bill Garrett | Indiana | |||||
| Bill Mlkvy | Temple | Dick Groat | Duke | |||||
| Sam Ranzino | North Carolina State | Gale McArthur | Oklahoma A&M | |||||
| Bill Spivey | Kentucky | Whitey Skoog | Minnesota | |||||
| Predecesor: 1950 |
All-American 1951 |
Sucesor: 1952 |