Los equipos All-American del baloncesto de la NCAA 1991, que destacan a los mejores jugadores universitarios de cada curso, fueron elegidos por Associated Press,[1] la USBWA, que es la asociación de periodistas de baloncesto de Estados Unidos, la United Press International y la Asociación Nacional de Entrenadores de Baloncesto.
Para conseguir el estatus de "All-America consensuado", un jugador debe haber conseguido los mayores honores en las siguientes listas que se elaboran en todo el país: Associated Press, USBWA, United Press International y la National Association of Basketball Coaches.
| Jugador | Posición | Clase[2] | Equipo |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kenny Anderson | G | Sophomore | Georgia Tech |
| Jimmy Jackson | G/F | Sophomore | Ohio State |
| Larry Johnson | F | Senior | UNLV |
| Shaquille O'Neal | C | Sophomore | Louisiana State |
| Billy Owens | F | Junior | Syracuse |
| Jugador | Posición | Clase | Equipo |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stacey Augmon | F | Senior | UNLV |
| Keith Jennings | G | Senior | East Tennessee State |
| Christian Laettner | F | Junior | Duke |
| Eric Murdock | G | Senior | Providence |
| Steve Smith | G | Senior | Michigan State |
| Equipo All-America | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.er equipo | 2º equipo | 3.er equipo | |||||
| Jugador | Universidad | Jugador | Universidad | Jugador | Universidad | ||
| Associated Press[3] | Kenny Anderson | Georgia Tech | Christian Laettner | Duke | Calbert Cheaney | Indiana | |
| Stacey Augmon | UNLV | Jimmy Jackson | Ohio State | Keith Jennings | East Tennessee State | ||
| Larry Johnson | UNLV | Todd Day | Arkansas | Rodney Monroe | North Carolina State | ||
| Shaquille O'Neal | LSU | Eric Murdock | Providence | Dikembe Mutombo | Georgetown | ||
| Billy Owens | Syracuse | Steve Smith | Michigan State | Doug Smith | Missouri | ||
| USBWA[4] | Kenny Anderson | Georgia Tech | Christian Laettner | Duke | Sin tercer equipo | ||
| Jimmy Jackson | Ohio State | Stacey Augmon | UNLV | ||||
| Larry Johnson | UNLV | Calbert Cheaney | Indiana | ||||
| Shaquille O'Neal | LSU | Keith Jennings | East Tennessee State | ||||
| Billy Owens | Syracuse | Eric Murdock | Providence | ||||
| NABC[5] | Kenny Anderson | Georgia Tech | Christian Laettner | Duke | Calbert Cheaney | Indiana | |
| Larry Johnson | UNLV | Jimmy Jackson | Ohio State | Chris Corchiani | North Carolina State | ||
| Shaquille O'Neal | LSU | Keith Jennings | East Tennessee State | Todd Day | Arkansas | ||
| Billy Owens | Syracuse | Stacey Augmon | UNLV | Alonzo Mourning | Georgetown | ||
| Steve Smith | Michigan State | Rodney Monroe | North Carolina State | Eric Murdock | Providence | ||
| UPI[6] | Kenny Anderson | Georgia Tech | Christian Laettner | Duke | Calbert Cheaney | Indiana | |
| Jimmy Jackson | Ohio State | Stacey Augmon | UNLV | Keith Jennings | East Tennessee State | ||
| Larry Johnson | UNLV | Rodney Monroe | North Carolina State | Dikembe Mutombo | Georgetown | ||
| Shaquille O'Neal | LSU | Eric Murdock | Providence | Steve Smith | Michigan State | ||
| Billy Owens | Syracuse | Doug Smith | Missouri | Clarence Weatherspoon | Southern Miss | ||
| Predecesor: 1990 |
All-American 1991 |
Sucesor: 1992 |