The members of the team were Chuck Taylor, Trent Beretta, Orange Cassidy, Kris Statlander, and Wheeler Yuta. They were sometimes managed by Danhausen. The members of the team were legitimate best friends.[1] While teaming, Taylor was the more comedic member of the team with Beretta acting as the more serious partner.
The trio began to feud with the Inner Circle after Santana and Ortiz destroyed Taylor's mom Sue's van. On the September 16 episode of Dynamite, they defeated Santana and Ortiz in a Parking Lot Brawl.[8]
In 2021, the trio began a feud with Kip Sabian, Penelope Ford, and Miro. During the feud, Beretta ended up tearing his pectoral muscle and was out of action for months.[9] On the March 31 episode of Dynamite, Beretta returned to help Taylor and Cassidy defeat Miro and Sabian. During the match, Kris Statlander joined the team and helped take out Penelope Ford.[10]
Beretta again had to leave the group for a while because he needed to get spinal fusion surgery. While he was away, Wheeler Yuta joined the team.[11] The team joined the New Japan Pro-Wrestling stable CHAOS after being invited by Rocky Romero.[12] On the December 8 episode on Dynamite, Beretta returned from injury and helped save the team from a beatdown by The Elite.[13] At Beach Break, Cassidy defeated Adam Cole in an Unsanctioned Lights Out match. During the match, Danhausen made his AEW debut and helped distract Cole.[14] He then began to manage the team.
Beretta was not happy with the addition of Yuta to the team. On the April 8 episode of Rampage, Yuta lost a competitive match against Jon Moxley. After the match, Yuta left Best Friends to join William Regal and the Blackpool Combat Club.[15]
Statlander had to miss many months of action after she suffered a completely torn ACL and lateral meniscus in her right leg.[16]
On the October 12 episode of Dynamite, Cassidy defeated Pac to win the AEW All-Atlantic Championship. It was also Cassidy's first championship in AEW.[17]
On the April 3, 2024 episode of Dynamite, Best Friends faced the Young Bucks in a semi-final match of the AEW World Tag Team Championship tournament but lost. Best Friends went for their three-post hug after the match but Baretta ran and hit Cassidy with a knee, turning heel and leaving the group.[18]
At Double or Nothing, Cassidy defeated Beretta. Statlander also left the group after turning heel after attacking Willow Nightingale and joining Stokely Hathaway.[19]