Wiki Article

User talk:Marchjuly

Nguồn dữ liệu từ Wikipedia, hiển thị bởi DefZone.Net

[edit source]

I was about to post a question on Commons:Village pump/Copyright, but thought I'd run it by you first as I see you are quite experienced in this area. What did you make of my follow-up comments at Wikipedia:Help desk#Citing PhD certificate on the image elements and originality of text/structure? I was also looking at File:Columbia University PhD.jpg, in the lead at Doctor of Philosophy -- do you see that as distinct in some way, or equally problematic? I appreciate it. Whonting (talk) 13:29, 5 November 2026 (UTC)

Hi Whonting. Different countries have different practices when it comes to threshold of originality (TOO); it's not a case of one size fits all. The US has pretty much always had a comparatively higher threshold (i.e., required more creative input) than many other countries when it came to a work being eligible for copyright protection; for example, the UK used to follow more of a sweat of the brow approach until the last couple of years when its courts started to change their interpretation of that part of UK copyright law and countries like Australia still have a relatively low TOO. The information on Ireland's TOO, however, seems too unclear per c:COM:TOO Ireland to make an easy assessment. If it's closer to sweat of the brow than not (like Australia), the diploma probably would be seen as too complex/creative to be within the public domain because of the TOO. The text and the coats of arms elements on the diploma could each be eligible for copyright protection for different reasons.
FWIW, the Columbia diploma you linked to above is probaby not "own work" per se and never (like most Commons files) seems to have been assessed. Whether it's really OK for Commons might be something that needs to be further discussed on Commons, but it's for a US university which means different copyright laws would apply. Commons requires that the content it hosts be appropriately licensed under the copyright laws of both the US (where the Commons servers are located) and in the country of first publication as explained in c:COM:L. Both are the same for the Columbia diploma, but the difference between the two for the Unveristy of Dublin one could mean Commons can't host the file even if it would be considered public domain under US copyright law. You'll need to ask about that on Commons to see what others think. -- Marchjuly (talk) 20:17, 5 November 2026 (UTC)
Oh there's a lot I didn't know, thankyou for going into this in such depth. I will ask on Commons to see if anyone gives a different read on the the copyright of the certificate. Short of that, though, would you suggest moving it to being hosted on Wikipedia if it's deemed to be protected in Ireland? Whonting (talk) 23:21, 5 November 2026 (UTC)
If it's considered protected in Ireland but not in the US, then it might be possible to host the file locally as {{PD-ineligible-USonly}}; however, there's really no need to do that if the only reason would be to try to cite it as a source because images in general tend to not be considered a reliable source for Wikipedia's purposes. In such a case, it would be much better to look for another source (online or not) that would be better meet Wikpedia's definition of a reliable source. Now, if it's considered protected in both Ireland and the US, then the only way to upload it locally would be as non-free content. However, Wikipedia's non-free content policy is quite restrictive and in my opinion there would be no chance of this file satisfy either WP:FREER and WP:NFC#CS if the only reason was to upload the file to serve as some kind of citation in addition with the issue of it being considered non-reliable as a source. -- Marchjuly (talk) 01:01, 6 November 2026 (UTC)

ArbCom 2026 Elections voter message

[edit source]

Hello! Voting in the 2026 Arbitration Committee elections is now open until 23:59 (UTC) on Monday, 30 November 2026. All eligible users are allowed to vote. Users with alternate accounts may only vote once.

The Arbitration Committee is the panel of editors responsible for conducting the Wikipedia arbitration process. It has the authority to impose binding solutions to disputes between editors, primarily for serious conduct disputes the community has been unable to resolve. This includes the authority to impose site bans, topic bans, editing restrictions, and other measures needed to maintain our editing environment. The arbitration policy describes the Committee's roles and responsibilities in greater detail.

If you wish to participate in the 2026 election, please review the candidates and submit your choices on the voting page. If you no longer wish to receive these messages, you may add {{NoACEMM}} to your user talk page. MediaWiki message delivery (talk) 00:22, 17 November 2026 (UTC)