Wiki Article

User talk:Hoary

Nguồn dữ liệu từ Wikipedia, hiển thị bởi DefZone.Net

If I've posted something on your talk page, please reply there rather than here. Any new question or comment at the bottom of the page, please. If you post something here, I'll reply here.

Draft feedback

[edit source]

Hi Hoary, You kindly reviewed Draft:Bas Aarts and added comments. I followed your suggestion and added links to reviews of my books. However, your colleague Sulfurboy has now declined the submission. Could you have another look and see if the article can now be approved? Just to add, I looked at the Wikipedia entries of many of my colleagues of similar seniority and their Wikipedia entries are very similar to mine and have long been approved. Many thanks in advance. ~2026-43040-95 (talk) 09:48, 17 August 2026 (UTC)

Bas (if I may), with "have long been approved", you've partly explained the double standard. Creating articles, even articles about living people, used to require truthiness and perhaps a sprinkling of references but not much more. After abuse of such permissiveness, we clamped down on attempts at creating new articles. But as for feeble old articles, it takes time and effort either (A) to argue over whether they should be deleted or (B) to bolster them so that others don't call for their deletion. And therefore they tend to linger, feebly. ¶ Let's look at the boilerplate that Sulfurboy has attached. This draft lacks inline citations. Wikipedia's verifiability policy requires that all content be supported by reliable sources. We require inline citations (footnotes) to show which source supports which specific statement. / You must place an inline citation directly after: [i] quotations; [ii] any material whose verifiability is likely to be challenged or is contentious; [iii] any material about living people. Within that, [iii] is the problem. And for most purposes the reliable source must be independent of the article's subject. (The enjoyment of perusal of maps isn't an achievement and so we can take the subject's [published] word for it; if the subject went on to describe his collection of copies of Stielers Handatlas, no, that would need a source that was independent as well as reliable.) ¶ I intend to work on the draft, improving it. I'm a slow worker and my "real life" has its demands. Better not resubmit the draft until I (or another "reviewer" posts a comment suggesting you to do so. Please be patient. -- Hoary (talk)WWU 👍︎ 12:04, 17 August 2026 (UTC)
Thanks, that's very helpful. ~2026-43040-95 (talk) 15:32, 17 August 2026 (UTC)
Have resubmitted. Thanks so much for your extensive work on this article. Very much appreciated! ~2026-46450-70 (talk) 11:11, 26 August 2026 (UTC)
Happy to infer that you don't dislike it. I think the said "extensive work" has led the article to wobble oddly between uninformativeness and verbosity -- but that though it's not a "good article", it's passable (or "standards compliant"). It should survive, and I hope that over time it will be improved. ¶ Sometime soon, please read, or reread, Wikipedia:Conflict of interest. ¶ Know somebody with both a taste for article creation and some free time? There are worse options than Draft:Hendrik Poutsma. -- Hoary (talk)WWU 👍︎ 23:33, 26 August 2026 (UTC)
I do like the article. Thanks again for your very valuable input! I'll think about Poutsma. He certainly deserves an entry, if only for his massive 4-volume English grammar. They don't write them like that any more.... ~2026-46729-39 (talk) 09:45, 27 August 2026 (UTC)

By contrast, there is an article about Kruisinga -- in reality not so much of a contrast, as the article somehow manages not to mention Kruisinga's giant Handbook. Jespersen's Modern English Grammar -- the only one of these three monsters that I've actually seen -- has an article to itself; and for each of the "parts" (volumes), the article has a list of chapters. The lists are there because I put them there; and, ahem, one motive for putting them there was my own convenience. Hardly "convenience", though; more "reduction of inconvenience". The only antique I look into more than very occasionally is Hans Marchand's Categories and Types (1969), which, refreshingly, is a single, well-ordered volume. -- Hoary (talk)WWU 👍︎ 11:05, 27 August 2026 (UTC)

You're a linguist? ~2026-46729-39 (talk) 13:24, 27 August 2026 (UTC)
Just a nobody with an internet connection. -- Hoary (talk)WWU 👍︎ 22:06, 27 August 2026 (UTC)

Revdelete

[edit source]

Hi, I noticed you deleted a revision on the sandbox. Can you also delete [1] and [2] because it is also a BLP violation and contains a disgusting joke? Beyoncé and Rihanna's navy 🐝🪖 13:11, 22 August 2026 (UTC)

Done. Thank you, Beyhive Navy. -- Hoary (talk)WWU 👍︎ 21:24, 22 August 2026 (UTC)

Request for guidance

[edit source]

Hi Hoary, please, I’d like to ask for some guidance regarding a situation that has been going on for a while.

I’ve had to deal with repeated confrontations from a particular Wikipedia editor, Dolpina, regarding articles I have created, including on the relevant talk pages:

here

here

For example, on the Jioji cloth article, she added a “citation needed” template even though the paragraph already had a citation supporting it: "diff" here

I have raised this issue on your talk page before. She also went to the talk page of the AfC reviewer who approved the article and challenged him to the point that he eventually complained of harassment on her talk page: here

I opened a content dispute regarding the matter, but she declined to participate: "Dispute Resolution Noticeboard" here

More recently, after I spoke with another AfC reviewer about a draft I had submitted where the original creator was suspected of using an LLM, something I was not aware of she went to the talk page of another editor whom she frequently involves in disputes and tagged another AfC-approved article I had created as potentially LLM-generated, apparently based only on suspicion: here

I understand that articles I create are open to improvement, scrutiny, and legitimate content disputes. However, I am becoming concerned about the pattern of repeated confrontations involving articles I have created, particularly when they appear to be coming from the same editor. At this point, it is beginning to feel as though I am being specifically targeted. How about neutral editing?. This doesn't seem like it.

My question is whether there is an appropriate venue or process through which I can raise this issue. She declined the content dispute I opened, but the behavior regarding articles I create have continued. I had also observed in her talk page before she blanked out everything that there's a pattern of such confrontations with articles regarding the same ethnic group that I mainly write on. I can provide the diffs via edit history if necessary.

I would appreciate your guidance on how best to handle this situation and whether there is anything I can do to address this situation that seems to me to be a continuos pattern

Thank you. Dreune (talk) 02:37, 28 August 2026 (UTC)

I see what you mean, Dreune. I'm thinking. Meanwhile, I've commented at Talk:Jioji cloth. -- Hoary (talk)WWU 👍︎ 08:04, 28 August 2026 (UTC)
Thanks a lot for the intervention. I'd provide the required further sources for the assessment. Dreune (talk) 08:52, 28 August 2026 (UTC)

Randy Allen Harris page

[edit source]

Not entirely sure how to go about this, but you seem to be the person who approved this page so I'm hoping you're at least the first place to start with this query. I am the subject of the page. It's perfectly fine, very accurate except for a few small things which I corrected when I first encountered it a little while ago. But I have been approached by a company that wants to 'enhance' the page, which frankly sounds like a good idea for professional reasons. I am applying for a grant this fall and an online presence helps a lot with that. The process does seem a bit too promotional, however, and somewhat against the spirit of Wikipedia, so I'm wondering how editors and admins regard services like this and whether in general they operate within the standards of the site or they tend to be hyperbolic. Thanks for anything you might tell me or anywhere you might direct me for an answer. --randy ~2026-36622-39 (talk) 20:52, 31 August 2026 (UTC)

Hello ProfRaha! At a wild guess, the company is rather less interested in "enhancing" your article than in receiving your payment for the promise of enhancing it. (For more on this, see WP:Scam warning.) The article's history shows that you have been making edits to the article. You were candid about your identity (thank you), but please don't continue doing this. First, please digest WP:FAQ/Article subjects. The "talk page" for the article Randy Allen Harris is Talk:Randy Allen Harris (so far, virtually unused); but rather than making edit requests there directly, you're better off doing so via Wikipedia:Edit Request Wizard/COI. When doing this (or anything else), make sure that you're logged in as ProfRaha. If you've already managed to mislay your password, you can have it emailed to you. Start off with two or three discrete, minor requests for improvements; if these go down well (as they probably will), you can gradually step up the ambitiousness of the requests.
Specifics: First, on (I quote) The information about my children is accurate; unclear why a citation is needed or what that citation would be. Wikipedia is deeply conservative (small "c"). It must not publish information (or misinformation?) that hasn't already been published elsewhere by reliable sources. Doubly so for (mis?) information about people who aren't public figures. Secondly, if you happen to find Newmeyer's Linguistic Theory in America and/or Postal's "Anarchy notes" and have the time & energy to skimread it/them, then a related edit request would be most welcome. -- Hoary (talk)WWU 👍︎ 22:40, 31 August 2026 (UTC)

Randy Allen Harris page

[edit source]

(The reply option was inactive, so I'm adding a topic.) Thanks very kindly. That's clear and helpful. I had no doubt they were after my money; I just wasn't sure if such groups were reputable or if they compromised pages because of the commercial motivation. I'll decline, send the conversation to paid-en-wp[[3]]wikipedia.org, will avoid making direct edits on my own page, and move over to the appropriate talk page to make some minor suggestions. I don't really have any ambitious plans for my own page. It does everything it needs to do, from what I can tell, in terms of coverage and accuracy. I was only interested in making it somewhat more appealing to grant adjudicators to help me keep supporting my students. I do have a new book coming out next year, as well as a few other projects, and will probably put them on the talk page when they appear. Thanks again, --randy ~2026-36622-39 (talk) 11:40, 1 September 2026 (UTC)

Thank you for dealing with vandalism

[edit source]

Thank you, Hoary, for dealing with the vandalism at the article about musician Crystal Taliefero. I posted about this in the Teahouse. Appreciate your stepping in. – Kekki1978 (talk ✉ | contribs ✎) 23:43, 25 September 2026 (UTC)

Happy to have helped, Kekki1978. The "semi-protection" is set to end on 3 October; if the silliness resumes after that, don't hesitate to let me know. -- Hoary (talk)WWU 👍︎ 23:55, 25 September 2026 (UTC)

Femmage (?)

[edit source]

Hello Hoary, I see that some 19 years back you were involved in discussions about the article 'Femmage', which is now just a re-direct to Louise Lidströmer -presumably re-created from scratch as it has no history... Do you happen to recall whether there was any significant material (or, more helpfully, refs) in any such previous existence? TIA, - Yadsalohcin (talk) 09:41, 8 October 2026 (UTC)

Yadsalohcin, I have no memory of this. But I looked at the "deleted" article. It says very little: virtually nothing that's not in this recent addition of yours. It has but one reference, for the catalogue/book by Cavalli-Björkman and Lidströmer that the current article cites. Why "virtually", above? Because this reference points out (rightly or wrongly) that the catalogue/book was published in Stockholm. Sorry not to have found anything more interesting; good luck editing. -- Hoary (talk)WWU 👍︎ 11:04, 8 October 2026 (UTC)
@Hoary and thanks a posteriori- ok so nothing special extra, then! Best wishes, -Yadsalohcin (talk) 13:13, 8 October 2026 (UTC)

Shūkan Post

[edit source]

Hi Hoary,

In this edit [4] you removed Kowal2701's AI-generated tag from Shūkan Post.

I believe the following are clear instances of WP:AIATTR, very typical of recent LLM:

According to the media critic Kiyoshi Hanada the Japan Audit Bureau of Circulations (JABI) reported sold copies of about 306,010 for the first half of 2008 and 297,120 for the second, placing the magazine third among the country's general weeklies.

Shogakukan's National Diet Library catalog records show the two titles in direct succession

As of September 2026 the publisher's media guide states that Shūkan Post's printing-certified circulation stands at 241,625 copies.

I have not done a detailed source/text check since all sources are in Japanese, though I can do so if you think it necessary. The author has acknowledged LLM use at WP:AI noticeboard/Kagerou47 but did not mention this specific article. Would be interested in hearing your reasoning on this article and why you don't think it should be tagged. Thank you! M kuhner (talk) 14:35, 18 October 2026 (UTC)

M kuhner, the first of these three seems only slightly odd to me. (Normally, I'd lop off "According to the media critic Kiyoshi Hanada", but some contexts might have me include it.) I see nothing even slightly odd about the second or third or the combination of all three. But if you think the warning template is warranted, feel free to reattach it. -- Hoary (talk)WWU 👍︎ 22:23, 18 October 2026 (UTC)

A barnstar for you!

[edit source]
The Original Barnstar
Thanks Hoary for Elaborating to my Teahouse answer. Bennett Li11 (Talk to Me) 05:09, 3 November 2026 (UTC)

Thanks giving to Mr.Hoary❤️🌹

[edit source]

Message Hello Hoary, Thank you very much for taking the time to explain Wikimedia Commons and copyright issues in detail. I appreciate your advice and understand the importance of respecting copyright regulations when using or uploading photographs. I will follow your recommendation and concentrate first on improving my text editing skills, using reliable references and official historical sources, and ensuring that my contributions comply with Wikipedia's policies and guidelines. My intention is to contribute accurate and properly referenced historical, cultural, educational and social information, particularly about Sri Lanka. I am still learning, and I sincerely welcome constructive guidance from experienced Wikipedia editors. Once I become more familiar with the editing standards, I hope to contribute photographs that I own or have permission to share under an appropriate free licence. Thank you again for your valuable advice and encouragement. Kind regards, Hajiani, AMB Dr. Seyed Firdawoosbee Hanifdeen — Preceding unsigned comment added by Hajiani, AMB Dr.Seyed Firdawoosbee Hanifdeen (talk • contribs) 11:05, 3 November 2026 (UTC)

Happy First Edit Day!

[edit source]
Hey, Hoary. I'd like to wish you a wonderful First Edit Day on behalf of the Wikipedia Birthday Committee!
Have a great day!
☘︎☘︎☘︎ALEXHammeke (talk | guestbook | sandbox) 05:38, 6 November 2026 (UTC)
☘︎☘︎☘︎ALEXHammeke (talk | guestbook | sandbox) 05:38, 6 November 2026 (UTC)

Happy First Edit Day!

[edit source]
Hey, Hoary. Just stopping by to wish you a Happy Wiki-Birthday from the Wikipedia Birthday Committee!
Have a great day!
Zahrazamedahmedi 💬My Talk Page💬 🫗My Mistakes🫗 09:02, 6 November 2026 (UTC)

Zahrazamedahmedi 💬My Talk Page💬 🫗My Mistakes🫗 09:02, 6 November 2026 (UTC)

Happy First Edit Day!

[edit source]

Happy First Edit Day! :-)

[edit source]
Wishing Hoary a very happy first edit day on behalf of the Wikipedia Birthday Committee! Ren ☺ (Talk) 19:15, 6 November 2026 (UTC)

Clarification of references in Draft:Julio Mancebo

[edit source]

Hello Hoary,

Thank you for your helpful comment on Draft Mancebo.

You were correct that the contributions by Ricardo Viera Orsi and José da Cruz are separate chapters in the same multilingual volume, Mancebo (2009), which explains the shared ISBN.

I have now clarified the chapter authors, titles and relevant page references in the draft.

Thank you again for your time and assistance.

Best regards,

AndersConstructiv AndersConstructiv (talk) 08:55, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

ArbCom 2026 Elections voter message

[edit source]

Hello! Voting in the 2026 Arbitration Committee elections is now open until 23:59 (UTC) on Monday, 30 November 2026. All eligible users are allowed to vote. Users with alternate accounts may only vote once.

The Arbitration Committee is the panel of editors responsible for conducting the Wikipedia arbitration process. It has the authority to impose binding solutions to disputes between editors, primarily for serious conduct disputes the community has been unable to resolve. This includes the authority to impose site bans, topic bans, editing restrictions, and other measures needed to maintain our editing environment. The arbitration policy describes the Committee's roles and responsibilities in greater detail.

If you wish to participate in the 2026 election, please review the candidates and submit your choices on the voting page. If you no longer wish to receive these messages, you may add {{NoACEMM}} to your user talk page. MediaWiki message delivery (talk) 00:09, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

New cross-language page link: Higashikawa Prize

[edit source]

A new page Premio Higashikawa on the Italian Wikipedia has been linked to the page Higashikawa Prize, which you created, via Wikidata (Q3109378).

You will not be notified about future links to pages you created. To opt in to these notifications, follow the opt-in instructions.

NervousBot (talk) 15:34, 19 November 2026 (UTC)